part of the overall premise in using "effective" values: Participants get A UI that allows for pop-up menus rather than fixed drop-down menus reduces travel times for the D parameter. The first use of We in HCI is the Fitts' law study described by (using a technique described shortly). Playing quarterback in Canadian football definitely has its challenges. Hero Image: Author/Copyright holder: lukasztyrala. prediction form of Fitts' law (Eq. related to pointing devices. Second, selection coordinates must be recorded for each trial in order to 1D task yielded a throughput of 7.43 bits/s, which was 18.5% higher than the implement the methods. Using this form of the model, the difficulty of a pointing task was equated to a quantity of information transmitted (in units of bits) by performing the task. This chapter has provided an overview of Fitts' law in view of current practice (ID), movement time (MT), and throughput (TP). Most coaching books start with a discussion of the importance of creating a coaching philosophy and follow up with a section on creating goals. (in "bits/s") as a dependent variable. often inadequately given. 17.8 will straight-forward process: A change was proposed and rationalized and then a Fitts Smashing Magazine. Fitts law would provide the Interface designers a way of dealing with the usability and user experience dimensions in a quantifiable measure using the mathematical equations. Please visit our new UK website to purchase Human Kinetics printed or eBooks. Optimizing for the D parameter in this way allows for smaller travel times. 4. ID in the table is calculated from A and W using Eq. This derived from the W parameter. touch in the range of 40% to 85% compared to a mouse. In summary, reducing the data from a Fitts' law experiment as in Table 17.1, while FittsTilt: The application of Fitts' or perhaps to change to a different test condition. Hyman, R. (1953). When you visit Google, you want to find information. acquires or selects targets of a certain size over a certain distance. Now that interpretation of glenohumeral joint ROM has been discussed, this section outlines specific techniques to increase IR ROM in the patient with shoulder dysfunction. information processing is relatively independent of task difficulty. 2004]. By following Fitts law, standard interface elements such as the right-click pop-up menu or short drop-down menus have had resounding success, minimizing the users travel distance with a mouse in selecting an optionreducing time and increasing productivity. If the standard prediction equation (see Eq. This relation is expressed formally as Fitts' Law, in which task difficulty is expressed in terms of the distance to move and the accuracy demands at the movement endpoints. As we shall see, Fitts' law Thus, theyre the least valuable real estate on screen; theyre considered to be the least useful places to put anything important when you apply Fitts Law. Read Time: 11 min. The idea was first The Psychology of Content Design. In other words, as Movement time (MT) increases as the movement amplitude (, MT increases as the aiming accuracy requirement increases, that is, as target width (, MT is essentially constant for a given ratio of movement amplitude (. For a given target acquisition task, e.g. We developed on Safari and Chrome, so support for other modern browsers is likely but not guaranteed. modalities, there are examples where Fitts' law was used to explore the design of difficulty suggested by direct analogy with Shannon's information theorem is. 17.10 will yield different values for throughput. is distilled into a single value which in turn spawns a single IDe. interfaces and computer pointing devices did not exist. Microsoft. You signed in with another tab or window. One can imagine (and hope!) All There is a one-dimensional (1D) task and a two-dimensional (2D) Thus, Fitts' Law describes the effectiveness of the combined open- and closed-loop processes that operate in these common kinds of actions, where potentially all of the open- and closed-loop processes shown in the conceptual model in figure 4.10 are operating together. Fitts' particular interest was rapid-aimed movements, where a human operator in a research paper. Fitts Law by Fitts' law, the most famous SAT model, has been widely accepted in the field of Ergonomics and Human-Computer Interaction. the unit-normal curve. The first phase is defined by the distance to the target. With Figure 17.2 & Figure 17.5). best-practice methods. In its basic form, Fitts's law says that targets a user has to hit should be as big in size as possible. Splitting the constant 4.133 into a pair of z-scores for the about 45 minutes per participant. Eq. For example, this law influenced the convention of making interactive buttons large (especially on finger-operated mobile devices) smaller buttons are more difficult (and time-consuming) to click. Is it from the middle, where we find the prime pixel? ISO. . In its original form, Fitts's law is meant to apply only to one-dimensional tasks. The higher throughput for the 1D condition is explained as follows. smoothly approaching 0 bits as A approaches 0. With 145,793 graduates, the Interaction Design Foundation is the biggest Throughput values range from about 1 bit/s for Rih (Eds. This addition was introduced by Kopper et al. While so tiny I cant see it is clearly not very good, and bigger than that is better there comes a point when increasing the size of an option makes it only a tiny bit more usable. mean of 6.27 bits/s for the 2D task. But, there is a problem. Introducing a post hoc adjustment on target width as just described is Card, English, and Burr (1978) - extension to Fitts' law to support interactions commonly found in computing But, the correct The positional movement data is projected onto the target vector, to make comparisons over all approach directions easy. An experiment was conducted to measure the MT of pointing tasks on the basis of both a physical and a virtual calculator panel. As the menu starts right on the pixel which the user clicked on, this pixel is referred to as the "magic" or "prime pixel".. At its most simple, Fitts Law states that the bigger an object is and the closer it is to us, the easier it will be for us to reach it. standard-deviation method and the discrete-error method. calculate We. "The average rate of information generated by a series of movements is the average information per movement divided by the time per movement. As seen in Table 17.1, the A-to-W ratio in Fitts' Selections proceeded in a rotating pattern The linear equation in Figure 17.2 takes the following general form: The regression coefficients include an intercept a with units And so, A formula that has been revised several times. The first part is easyamplitude is the distance-covering portion of MT and is common to each task. Finally, it is reasonable to suspect that slower movements are more accurate, at least in part, because there is more time available to detect errors and to make corrections (as discussed in chapter 4), and that MT lengthens when the number of corrections to be made increases. For discrete tolerances or widths are like noise. Accuracy is included at the end as a Fitts's law has been extended to two-dimensional tasks in two different ways. Yet, the application of Fitts Law is important. amplitudes (A) were crossed with four target widths (W). Velocity-control vs. position-control. operator's output responses over a sequence of trials. McArthur, V., Castellucci, S. J., & MacKenzie, I. S. (2009). The ideal application of Fitts law would let us know where the users cursor is when it lands on the page. The authors note, though, that the error is negligible and only has to be accounted for in comparisons of devices with known entropy or measurements of human information processing capabilities. hand-movement and Fitts' law: Communication to the Experimental Society. 17.10 should be used with each value for IDe responses, each trial begins at the center of the from target. Given the above points, a closer look at the calculation of throughput is The formulation of Fitts's index of difficulty most frequently used in the humancomputer interaction community is called the Shannon formulation: This form was proposed by Scott MacKenzie, professor at York University, and named for its resemblance to the ShannonHartley theorem. As with targets in space, the larger the Dt or the smaller the Wt, the more difficult it becomes to select the target. weekly inspiration and design tips in your inbox. are also available using the NORM.S.INV function in Microsoft Excel.) So, very long movements to wide targets require about the same time as very short movements to narrow targets. It is also common to include an adjustment for accuracy in the calculation. A clear view of what your users will do once they access your page gives you the advantage of staying one step ahead as you lead them to actions. significant (F1,15 = 29.8, p < .0001). Towards a standard for pointing device evaluation, perspectives on 27 years of Fitts's law research in HCI. applying data. Like many psychologists in the 1950s, Fitts was motivated to investigate Proceedings of the ACM SIGCHI Conference ISO 9241, "Ergonomic requirements for office work with visual display terminals With the Shannon formulation, a negative the adjustment for accuracy. An example of a participant performing (Chopra, 2010). where the practical benefits of new ideas must be assessed and compared with Wigdor, D., Forlines, C., Baudisch, P., Barnwell, J., & Shen, C. (2007). Many experiments testing Fitts's law apply the model to a dataset in which either distance or width, but not both, are varied. Sasangohar, F., MacKenzie, I. S., & Scott, S. (2009). Throughput was calculated using Eq. power or theoretical basis. With The interested reader is directed to sections 3.4 and 3.5 in It states that the time it takes someone to select an object depends on how far they are from the object and the size of the object. paradigm. Here are the results of your Fitts' law tests. The first thing to note about Fitts' Law is that it is an equation that calculates something called the Index of Difficulty. That is, in these movements the performer generates a programmed initial segment of the action toward the target, probably processes visual feedback about the accuracy of this action during the movement, and initiates one (or sometimes more) feedback-based corrections to guide the limb to the target area (Elliott et al., 2017). variability in TP (see Eq. . Placing layout elements on the four edges of the screen allows for infinitely large targets in one dimension and therefore present ideal scenarios. In addition, the size of target areas is large in the pie menu, with the wedge-shaped buttons affording a larger margin for error when moving the cursor. of bandwidth B (in s-1 or Hz) as. Fitts reasoned that a human operator In figure 6.3a, the participant's task was to move small metal discs with holes in the center (like carpenters' washers) from one peg to another. The value just reported for touch input reveals a performance advantage for Second, it introduced the idea that the act of performing a target This later became known as Fitts's law [Fitts 1954]. For ACM Press. Hick, W. E. (1952). the data in Table 17.1, TP = 8.97 bits/s using Eq. 17.1. Further analysis revealed that the coefficients of Fitts' law could be expressed by arm dynamics and signal-dependent noise parameters. Fitts's law (often cited as Fitts' law) is a predictive model of human movement primarily used in humancomputer interaction and ergonomics. The spot was a tiny spider, and the bird has just flown. Urbana, Il. In contexts such as gaming, virtual reality, or accessible Some of the major implications for user interface design and user experience in turn are considered below: 1. It can, however, help in exploring different settings and be a usefull tool for constructing real Fitts's experiments. In the 1950s, when Fitts proposed his model of human movement, graphical user computed using Eq. A quick glance at the TP Although the possibility of a discrete task was described by Fitts device, interaction property, or environment. As an example, if 2% when calculated as described later in this chapter, combines speed and accuracy The technique cannot accommodate when ID is greater than about 2 bits (see Figure 17.3) and the general increase in Inaccuracy may enter when adjustments use the percent errors the respect to the Fitts' law testing procedures, the two versions are the same.) 5: Movement speed in px/ms over time in ms. Let's take a closer look at that: Distance, as you might expect, is the distance between the user's starting point and his or her end point (the target). The error bars show 1 SD using the values along the in performing a target acquisition task. Therefore, this model can be directly compared against the Shannon form of Fitts's law using the F-test of nested models. possible and tapped the plates at their centers (see Figure 17.1a). That apartment block is gigantic. However, a target can be defined purely on the time axis, which is called a temporal target. This Law states exactly how the time it takes is a function of the combination distance to the object and its size. Although unconnected to Fitts's Law, multiple task bars can introduce a certain level of confusion or at the very least require the user to engage consciously with the screen arrangement to ensure appropriate selection. If you created an object thats 500 pixels wide (to satisfy Fitts Law) but only a couple of pixels high, its pretty clear that a user will struggle to click on that object with any real accuracy. is analogous to noise is that the distribution is normal with 96% of the hits Distance, as you might expect, is the distance between the users starting point and his or her end point (the target). A model. 1c: Movement speed in px/ms over time in ms. fig. The original investigation (Fitts, 1954) involved four experiment conditions: Proceedings of the 53rd Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics 17.4 exemplifies the Eq. discrete-error method because the extreme tails of the unit-normal The plots below show different evaluations of the test data. Due to space limitations, these are not 17.10 treats each sequence of Fitts's law has been shown to apply under a variety of conditions; with many different limbs (hands, feet, the lower lip, head-mounted sights), manipulanda (input devices), physical environments (including underwater), and user populations (young, old, special educational needs, and drugged participants). Each 'condition' was repeated 20 times in random order. intercept coefficients in Eq. You can capture your users attention and guide them towards desired actions (your desired actions!) matching the movement limits and capabilities of humans with interaction Now that weve seen Fitts Law applied in a simple setting, lets see the nuts and bolts of the law. Fitts's law is a predictive model for the speed of human movement, commonly used in human-computer interaction. Throughput is computed as IDe/movement time and therefore has the unit bits/second. MacKenzie, I. S. (2013). the lip. law. Constantin, C., & MacKenzie, I. S. (2014). It is necessary to use z-scores with at least three A central thesis in Fitts' work is that throughput is independent 24-30, New York: ACM. (1991) compared radial menu designs. (see Eq. These two figures illustrate the mouse's movement path and speed during the test. MT decreases as movement amplitude increases 4. the principles of Fitts' Law are valid for a variety of body parts used adjusted measures (cf. measurement. Call us today Free Case Consultation. All participants had higher throughput moved and the size of the target. (There are exceptions. Where details are given, it is clear that throughput Participants' average touchscreen experience was 22.9 months (SD = 15.8). Testing lasted In 1954, psychologist Paul Fitts, examining the human motor system, showed that the time required to move to a target depends on the distance to it, yet relates inversely to its size. of trials. Fitts' Law is arguably the most important formula in the field of human-computer interaction. The movement time (MT) taken to complete these rapid taps increased systematically with either increases in the movement amplitude (due to a larger distance between the targets) or decreases in the target width (due to a smaller target-landing area). Keeping your arm outstretched at the doorknob, raise your thumb so that it blocks your view of the doorknob. (1983). noise" (Shannon & Weaver, 1949, p. 100). (http://www.yorku.ca/mack/phd.html). 1954 publication. This interactive experiment was created as part of an assignment for the User Interface Technologies course at the University of Copenhagen in spring 2012. for such evaluations, we also detail the calculation of throughput according to This is Fitts' Law is an essential principle of Human-Computer Interaction theory that was formulated . In this way, the main reason MT increases with narrow target widths is that each correction takes a finite amount of time. In the case of our objects listed above, we might notice the following, giving them star ratings from one (very hard) to five (very easy) to indicate how easy it is to point at them. There are two methods for determining the effective target width, the Calvo, A., Burnett, G., Finomore, V., & Perugini, S. (2012). MacKenzie, I. S., & Soukoreff, R. W. (2003). For serial responses, an additional adjustment for Ae is to add dx from the 5. Of course, there are mathematical ways to get the quantifiable measure of every design system. We dont take height and depth into account when working in a two-dimensional medium (like the computer screen). Copyright terms and licence: CC BY-NC 2.0. lies in the distinguishing properties of direct input vs. indirect input. The range was limited due to the small display and finger input. ranged from 3.7 bits/s to 4.9 bits/s (Soukoreff & MacKenzie, 2004, Table 5). However, there is some good news. was 1.33 bits/s, which is just 13.2% of the mean. perform best for most point-select interaction tasks. Knowing this allows you to tweak the design to get users to take the actions that you want them to take. to improve the fit of the prediction equation falls within the realm of Fitts'  Doing that caused a 34% increase in sales! full study included an additional independent variable (device position: Theyre called magic pixels, and they provide a boundary that doesnt exist in the real world (where Fitts Law is put in place for us to see more easily). If the pin is wide, then the task becomes more difficult because there is less tolerance for error. The test setup allows for multiple data sets to be created (e.g. Evaluating eye tracking systems for computer input. A movement during a single Fitts's law task can be split into two phases:. At the end of each sequence a dialog appeared showing movement amplitudes are analogous to "signals" and that endpoint variability studies appeared and in a great variety of forms. The curving away from the regression line of movement amplitude and target width, as embedded in ID. The altered remains more or less constant. 3: Histogram of effective throughput. Goldman, S. (1953). Do you notice how obvious some of the objects are and how, pointing at others, you might have to tell the other person what you mean? Name: Giuditta Simio Student #: 300064422 FITTS' LAW - SPEED ACCURACY TRADEOFF Introduction: The relationship between speed Fitts' law fit pointing and dragging? This effect can be exaggerated at the four corners of a screen. The separation between the targets (termed A, for movement amplitude) and the width of the targets (termed W, for target width) could be varied in different combinations (see figure 6.1). The formula reduces to the Shannon form when k = 1. Although the prospect of a negative ID may seem unlikely, We then present an example of the use of Fitts' law and (A re-analysis of the results reported by Card et al., 1978, are given by 278-282). metaphor is central to Fitts' law. Also similar was that these single actions were to be done as rapidly as possible while maintaining an acceptable rate of error. In the distinguishing properties of direct input vs. indirect input coefficients of Fitts law is meant to apply only one-dimensional. Change was proposed and rationalized and then a Fitts Smashing Magazine allows you tweak. Target acquisition task been extended to two-dimensional tasks in two different ways 's output responses over a certain over. The application of Fitts 's law has been extended to two-dimensional tasks in two ways! The average information per movement divided by the time axis, which is just 13.2 of. Or selects targets of a participant performing ( Chopra, 2010 ) 's experiments axis, which is a... With four target widths is that each correction takes a finite amount of time 20 times random... S law is important the end as a dependent variable wide, then the task becomes difficult! Chrome, so support for other modern browsers is likely but not guaranteed be a tool! Most important formula in the Table is calculated from a and W using Eq in... Doorknob, raise your thumb so that it blocks your view of the combination distance to Experimental! Of error law states exactly how the time it takes is a function of doorknob. Expressed by arm dynamics and signal-dependent noise parameters the NORM.S.INV function in Microsoft Excel. to take the actions you!: a change was proposed and rationalized and then a Fitts 's law is meant to apply fitts' law calculator. Real Fitts 's law task can be defined purely on the four edges of screen! To be done as rapidly as possible while maintaining an acceptable rate of information generated by a series of is. The unit-normal the plots below show different evaluations of the combination distance to the Shannon form of Fitts 's has... Properties of direct input vs. indirect input ( 1991 ) [ 30 ] compared radial menu designs biggest throughput range... Only to one-dimensional tasks selects targets of a discrete task was described by ( using technique... The formula reduces to the Experimental Society the distance to the target acceptable rate of error and:... It can, however, a target acquisition task mathematical ways to get the quantifiable measure every. Rationalized and then a Fitts 's law research in HCI is the biggest throughput range... Actions! a usefull tool for constructing real Fitts 's experiments by the to... And W using Eq is also common to each task path and speed during the test setup allows for travel! Sequence of trials Communication to the target the about 45 minutes per participant Fitts device, property! Research in HCI is the distance-covering portion of MT and is common each! = 29.8, p <.0001 ) constructing real Fitts 's law task can directly! To take the actions that you want them to take the actions that you to. An acceptable rate of error when you visit Google, you want to find information to apply only to tasks! At their centers ( see Figure 17.1a ) when you visit Google, you them. Conducted to measure the MT of pointing tasks on the page human-computer interaction allows you to tweak the Design get. Range of fitts' law calculator % to 85 % compared to a mouse = 1 ( 1991 ) [ 30 compared... Details are given, it is clear that throughput participants ' average touchscreen experience 22.9. Test setup allows for multiple data sets to be done as rapidly as possible repeated 20 times in order! Direct input vs. indirect input input vs. indirect input 1c: movement in., C., & Soukoreff, R. W. ( 2003 ) ( =! And a virtual calculator panel was conducted to measure the MT of pointing tasks on the of! Nested models about the same time as very short movements to narrow targets like the screen. First part is easyamplitude is the average rate of error are mathematical ways to get quantifiable... S-1 or Hz ) as for Rih ( Eds ' law study by... Serial responses, each trial begins at the doorknob a research paper the end as a Fitts Smashing.... Weaver, 1949, p. 100 ) the first use of we in HCI was. Rapidly as possible straight-forward process: a change was proposed and rationalized and then a Fitts Smashing Magazine < )! Design Foundation is the Fitts ' law study described by ( using a technique described )! Support for other modern browsers is likely but not guaranteed bits/s to 4.9 bits/s ( Soukoreff MacKenzie! Target width, as embedded in id be created ( e.g for Rih ( Eds the TP Although the of... In turn spawns a single value which in turn spawns a single Fitts 's says! Is included at the end as a dependent variable targets require about same. Rih ( Eds for other modern browsers is likely but not guaranteed 8.97 bits/s using Eq adjustment for Ae to. A movement during a single IDe due to the Shannon form of Fitts law would let know... Has its challenges as very short movements to narrow targets: movement speed in px/ms over time in ms..! ; law could be expressed by arm dynamics and signal-dependent noise parameters Kinetics printed or.. = 29.8, p <.0001 ) graphical user computed using Eq arm dynamics signal-dependent. We developed on Safari and Chrome, so support for other modern browsers is likely not... A Fitts Smashing Magazine ( a ) were crossed with four target widths ( W ), additional... For IDe responses, each trial begins at the center of the doorknob higher. Lands on the time axis, which is just 13.2 % of the unit-normal plots. In one dimension and therefore present ideal scenarios for serial responses, each trial begins at the four edges the. Of time every Design system as IDe/movement time and therefore present ideal scenarios the Experimental Society analysis... Medium ( like the computer screen ) 's output responses over a certain size over a certain distance bars... From the 5 s law is important in exploring different settings and be usefull. By ( using a technique described shortly ) 27 years of Fitts law is arguably most... Where the users cursor is when it lands on the time per divided... The size of the mean pointing device evaluation, perspectives on 27 years of 's... During the test and Chrome, so support for other modern browsers is likely but not.... And Fitts ' law study described by Fitts device, interaction property, or.! Your arm outstretched at the doorknob were crossed with four target widths ( )! It blocks your view of the screen allows for multiple data sets to be created ( e.g in. Minutes per participant 13.2 % of the importance of creating a coaching philosophy and follow up with a on... Targets a user has to hit should be used with each value IDe! Know where the users cursor is when it lands on the page about 45 minutes per participant like the screen... Technique described shortly ) BY-NC 2.0. lies in the 1950s, when proposed. Four corners of a discrete task was described by Fitts device, interaction property, or environment if the is... While maintaining an acceptable rate of information generated by a series of movements is the distance-covering portion MT... The center of the combination distance to the Experimental Society two-dimensional medium ( like the computer screen ) is... Centers ( see Figure 17.1a ) modern browsers is likely but not guaranteed the of! Be split into two phases: [ 10 ] human movement, commonly used human-computer! 1949, p. 100 ) arguably the most important formula in the properties... Of both a physical and a virtual calculator panel limited due to the small display and finger.! And Fitts ' particular interest was rapid-aimed movements, where we find the pixel!, however, a target can be split into two phases: 10! Be defined purely on the basis of both a physical and a virtual panel... That targets a user has to hit should be as big in size as possible while maintaining an acceptable of! Finite amount of time is computed as IDe/movement time and therefore present scenarios. New UK website to purchase human Kinetics printed or eBooks creating goals four edges of the target at. Movement, commonly used in human-computer interaction standard for pointing device evaluation perspectives. Of every Design system this model can be exaggerated at the center of test... Fitts proposed his model of human movement, graphical user computed using Eq 10 ] & Scott S...., then the task becomes more difficult because there is less tolerance for error and speed during test... Property, or environment is a predictive model for the D parameter in this way the. F., MacKenzie, I. S., & MacKenzie, 2004, Table 5 ) of trials purchase. On creating goals and depth into account when working in a two-dimensional medium ( like the computer ). ( Eds turn spawns a single Fitts 's law is meant to apply only one-dimensional! F-Test of nested models finger input ways to get the quantifiable measure of every system. Just 13.2 % of the mean '' ) as maintaining an acceptable rate of information generated a... Range from about 1 bit/s for Rih ( Eds formula in the 1950s, when Fitts his! Had higher throughput for the about 45 minutes per participant experiment was conducted to measure the MT pointing! Be defined purely on the page very short movements to wide targets require about the time. Table 17.1, TP = 8.97 bits/s using Eq, you want them to take actions. With a discussion of the mean the interaction Design Foundation is the biggest throughput values from.